Gay man Robert Mandelbaum told to marry woman or son would lose inheritance
The gay son of a deceased New York City businessman is fighting a stipulation in his late father's will that required him to marry the mother of his child or risk losing the child's inheritance.
Robert Mandelbaum, who is a Manhattan Criminal Court judge, said in court documents that his father, Frank Mandelbaum, knew he was gay and included his male partner in family activities. The elder Mandelbaum died in 2007 at the age of 73.
Mandelbaum, who amassed a fortune after founding the ID-verification firm Intellicheck, died before his grandson, Cooper, now 16 months, was born.
Cooper's fathers, Robert Mandelbaum and Jonathan O'Donnell, married shortly after his birth via surrogate in 2011. It's unclear which of the men is Cooper's biological father.
The late businessman's will left behind a $180,000 trust for his grandchildren, including those who would be born after his death. The heirs will receive installments from ages 25 to 30, although the amounts will be contingent on the performance of the investment.
But Cooper will not be eligible for his inheritance because he has two dads, according to the terms of the will.
The words "child," "grandchild" and "descendant" include natural and adopted children and children born out of wedlock, according to the will, which was filed in Manhattan Surrogate's Court.
"However, such words shall specifically not include an adopted child of Robert, if adopted while Robert is a single person, or a biological child of Robert, if Robert shall not be married to the child's mother within six months of the child's birth," the will states.
Robert Mandelbaum is challenging the will on the basis that it would require him to enter into a "sham marriage" which would violate New York marriage-equality law.
Attorney Anne Bederka wrote that the stipulation Robert Mandelbaum marry a woman was "tantamount to expecting him either to live in celibacy, or to engage in extramarital activity with another man, and is therefore contrary to public policy."
"There is no doubt that what [Frank Mandelbaum] has sought to do is induce Robert to marry a woman," Bederka wrote.
A settlement has not yet been approved by the Manhattan Surrogate's Court.
A young woman who was left with a permanent brain injury while working as an extra on the movie Transformers 3 received an $18.5 million ... Full story
- World cup fan Richard Swanson killed in tragic accident
- Richard DeCoatsworth: Ex-Pa. officer once hailed as hero faces charges
- US Airways plane makes unusual belly landing at Newark airport
- Daytona Woman Katie Burson Dies After House Party Shooting
- Up to 60 people injured in Virginia hikers parade crash
- Milwaukee bra ban is lifted after publicity campaign
- Navy SEAL Jonathan Kaloust dies in Fort Knox training accident
- Inmate sues Taco Bell: Claims Doritos Locos was his idea
- Waitress gets $446 tip from $6 order
- Savannah Nash: Girl, 16, killed after 'texting and driving on her first solo drive'
- Theater critic Kevin Williamson smashes cellphone of woman who wouldn't stop using it during performance
- Bishop Larry Trotter: Outrage after picture of Chicago bishop sharing bathtub with granddaughter emerges on Instagram
- WATCH: Heartless thief steals 'Toys for Tots' donations box
- Moment the tsunami wave rolled into San Francisco Bay captured on film
- Texas father, daughter die in fiery plane crash - after surviving similar crash
- John Adams Elementary School teacher Justin Coleman indicted on child porn charges
- Judge brands newly-wed Dalia Dippolito 'pure evil' jails her for 20 yrs over plot to kill husband
- Two bombs found inside borders bookstore in Denver shopping mall - FBI called in
- Lauren Spierer: Missing student's father issue tearful plea to friends' parents
- Juggalos arrested for causing disturbance
- Caught On Tape: Gunmen Open Fire On SEPTA Bus in Philadelphia
- Utah officer Jared Francom killed, 6 others wounded in shootout
- NJ Doctor Sylvia Lee 'stabbed her adopted daughter 100 times with a screwdriver for wrongly washing dog clothes'
- Florida Dad Shot Three Times By Crazy Mother-in-law (video)
- John Atterberry dead: Music Executive killed after Hollywood shooting rampage
- 3 FAMU Band Members Sean Hobson, Aaron Golson, and James Harris Charged with Hazing
- Husband charged with killing wife Lilia Blandin in Walmart
- Interracial marriage in US hits new high: 1 in 12
- James Hooker, California High School Teacher, Leaves Job And Family For Former Student
- Ohio man Kevin Allen kills wife Katherina Allen, daughter at Cracker Barrel
- Racy photo of girlfriend’s breasts leads FBI to hacker Higinio O. Ochoa
- Louisiana woman Sharmeka Moffitt set alight by three men who also scrawled KKK on her car
- 'Most of the city is under water': Thousands flee Atlantic City as historic boardwalk is threatened by devastating floods
- Ohio woman Shena Hardin who drove on sidewalk must wear 'idiot' sign
- Tanning salon owner Henry Hamilton 'kills himself because President was re-elected' - and scrawls 'F*** Obama' on his will
- Probe begins into rush-hour train smash
- Jaw-dropping 101.73-carat diamond that took 21 MONTHS to polish sells for $26.7million
- Lauren Block: Stripper DIES one week after falling head first off gentleman's club balcony during 'lap dance gone wrong'
- Twin sisters brawling in middle of the street are killed by hit and run driver
- 'Wrap your legs around my head': Married Fox weatherman Geoff Fox fired after 'inappropriate' sexting chats with female photographer 18
- James Taylor Named By Colleagues As Pilot From Cockpit Rant 17
- Babysitter Loni Bouchard 'had sex with boy, 14, she was hired to look after' 16
- Daytona Woman Katie Burson Dies After House Party Shooting 10
- Florida woman Danisa Landaeta arrested for drawing picture of bomb on friend's bag at Miami International Airport 10
- Teenage Boy Cody Riddle Drowns In Boone Lake 8
- Dunkin' Donuts employee Melissa Redmond busted for prostitution; sold sex out of restaurant 7
- Motorcycle Plunges Off Route 1, Chelsea Man Cory White Killed 6
- Pharmacy Owner Babubhai Patel Accused Of Fraud Wants Out Of Jail 5
- Pictured: The moment handcuffed woman Danielle Maudsley, was left brain dead after being Tasered for trying to escape police 5
- Glenda Moore: Mother whose boys were swept out of her arms was left screaming on street for 12 hours 5
- Tanya Angus: Woman fighting gigantism dies suddenly aged 34 after growing to nearly 7ft and 400lbs 5
- Couple 'savagely beat son, three, for wetting his pants 4
- Florida woman Natasha Larson posed as husband's ex on Craiglist, posted steamy ads looking for casual sex 4
- Hormiz David, Ninos Yacoub, Ramina Badal Presumed Dead From Yosemite Fall 4
- Philadelphia judge Adam Beloff 'hangs himself after separating from his wife' 4
- Applebee's Waitress Chelsea Welch Fired For Sharing 'I Give God 10%' Tip Receipt 4
- Ohio Gym Teacher Stacy Schuler 'had sex with five students' 3
- Denver: Teens Phillip Abernathy and Connor Greenwall Accused Of Distributing Child Porn 3
- 'Stabbed over $20': Teenager 'killed brother's girlfriend Kamisha Richards over loan for diapers and milk 3
- Teacher, Sandra Hadsock, 64, charged with child abuse For Punching Student 3
- Video shows brutal racist attack on black man James Craig Anderson in Mississippi: prosecutors 3
- Novi Native Jackie Michon Killed In Chicago Accident 3
- Veteran teacher Jerry Buell suspended for gay bashing on Facebook 3
- NY Woman Minhee Cho outraged after Papa John's write racist name on her receipt 3
- Penn Judge Uses Sharia Law, Says Muslims Allowed to Attack People for Insulting Mohammad 3
- Florida Mother Dalina J. Nicholas 'repeatedly sold daughter, 6, for sex in return for drugs' 3
- Teacher Marilyn Bart Investigated for Race Conflict 3
- Revealed: Dramatic pictures of Trayvon's lifeless body as new evidence shows Zimmerman bleeding with 'broken nose' 3
- Pastor Charles Worley delivers shocking sermon calling for extermination of homosexuals 3
- Geoffrey McGann: 'Artist' carrying homemade 'watch bomb' with fuses and circuit board arrested at California airport 3
- Three women diners left furious after their check came with 'FAT GIRLS' written on top 3
- Jacqueline Baffoni: Teacher jokes about stabbing her middle school students with a fruit knife 3
- Bullied teen Baileigh Karam vanishes the same day shocking video of her being brutally attacked at school is filmed and posted online 3
- Bishop Larry Trotter: Outrage after picture of Chicago bishop sharing bathtub with granddaughter emerges on Instagram 3
- Judge bans father-of-four Asim Taylor who owes $100k child support from having any more kids 3
- Pit bull saves woman from fire 3
- Missing Lake Elsinore Mom Tanya Petro's Remains Found 2
- Police shootings in America: Sudden wave sparks fears of secret 'war on cops' 2
- Florida Mother Julie Schenecker shot her two teen children twice in the head 'for being mouthy' 2
Rate this article
|PHOTOS: Plastic Surgery Celebrity||Awkward family photos|
|UPDATED: Faces of Meth||PHOTOS: Celebrities all a-Twitter|