'Hot for Teacher' Essay Lands Student Joseph Corlett in Trouble
A Michigan college student is crying foul after he was kicked off campus for writing a sexually suggestive journal entry about his teacher for a class assignment.
Joseph Corlett, a 56-year-old countertop refinisher who is pursuing a degree in writing and rhetoric at Oakland University, wrote the essay as a part of a creative writing journal assignment in a writing course.
In his essay, which he said was inspired by the 1984 Van Halen hit "Hot for Teacher," he wrote about his first impressions of his professor, Pamela Mitzelfeld, describing her as "tall, blonde, stacked, smart, articulate."
Corlett said he was under the impression that there were no restrictions on what he could write about in his journal.
"The real issue is the First Amendment," Corlett said. "It's about academic freedom and about due process. These are the real issues of the case, and the sooner we can get past the titillation of it and see those issues, the better."
Mitzelfeld and Oakland University declined requests for comment from ABC News. But the university has made its position known in its disciplinary action against Corlett.
In January, after a campus hearing, the university found Corlett guilty of intimidation. Another charge, for sexual harassment, was dropped. Corlett was suspended for three semesters, banned from stepping foot on campus and required to seek out psychological counseling before he could be eligible to reenroll, according to documentation provided to ABC News by Corlett.
Corlett has appealed the punishment; the university's response is pending.
It all started in September, when Corlett began taking an advanced English class from Mitzelfeld, who had assigned the students to keep a journal, referred to as a "daybook," Corlett said. The daybooks were a place for students to collect unsensored thoughts, which could then be used to create more polished essays, according to Corlett.
Mitzelfeld collected Corlett's journal in November and that's when his problems began. Up until then, he said, he had been earning A's on his writing assignments, many of which had sexual undertones, he said, so he thought he was "on the right track" and was not concerned about turning in the daybook journal.
But after Mitzelfeld reviewed Corlett's daybook, she initiated a university review of his conduct, which led to a meeting with a dean, and instructions to stay away from Mitzelfeld's class for awhile, until she could cool down, Cortlett said. But when he eventually returned to class, he was escorted out of the room by university police, he said, and asked not to return pending a university judicial hearing.
Oakland University initially charged Corlett with sexual harassment and intimidation, both classified as "unlawful individual activities" in the school's student handbook.
Corlett, who lives in Lake Orion, is flummoxed by the turn of events. "I asked (Mitzelfeld) on multiple occasions if there were topical restrictions on the daybooks, and on every occasion -- often in front of other students -- she told me no," Corlett said.
After the university disciplined Corlett, he enlisted the help of a non-profit education foundation called the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, a Philadelphia-based non-profit that advocates for students and teachers. The Center helped him find Brian Vincent, a Michigan-based litigator, who is helping him challenge his suspension and the other disciplinary actions taken by Oakland University.
"I have no doubt in my mind that the university had no authority to boot him off campus," said Vincent. "His speech was completely protected, and the University of Oakland's actions at this point have been completely baseless and illegal."
University officials told ABC News they do not comment on student conduct matters.
Gene Policinski, executive director of the First Amendment Center, a non-profit education-focused organization at Vanderbilt University, said that harassment and intimidation charges are often handled on a case-by-case basis rather than based broadly on law.
"Because the law on harassment comes from protection of person who is hearing the speech, it can be a complicated factor," Polcinski said.
"Just because something is offensive doesn't mean that it is a criminal act,'' Polcinski said. "I think the First Amendment protects a wide range of freedom of expression. We're free to express even repellant ideas, but what grade he received is an academic -- not a legal -- question."
If the disciplinary actions are not dropped in the appeal, Corlett plans to file a lawsuit against the university, Vincent said.
"He suffered damage to his reputation," said Vincent. "He wants to be made whole for his attorney fees and wants to be reinstated to the university so he can finish his education, which he has a Constitutional right to do."
A TEXAN woman is facing criminal charges after breaking into the home of her husband's alleged mistress last weekend and creating chaos. Angela Siler-Fisher, 42, ... Full story
- Couple order McDonald’s breakfast, get served bag of cash
- Woman snaps the most selfish selfie ever
- Prison intern Kayla Danielle Davis charged with sexual assault
- Woman says 'attacker swung manhood in helicopter motion'
- Woman branded 'Half-Ton Killer' Mayra Rosales loses 600 lbs
- For sale: Man puts motorbike AND wife on Craigslist
- Actress sues doctors for posting drunk pictures of her on Facebook
- Brie Lybrand: New Orleans beauty queen's shocking video to 'rapist' father
- Florida woman Rashia Wilson who boasted she was the 'Queen of IRS tax fraud' on Facebook gets 21 years
- Beaten, starved, gang-raped and 'forced to give birth': Nigel Brennan and Amanda Lindhout's horrific ordeal as hostages in Somalia
- Insurance company uses Nelson Mandela’s death to promote itself
- University of Northern Virginia chancellor David Lee, 64, quits over sex-dungeon photos
- 'Wrap your legs around my head': Married Fox weatherman Geoff Fox fired after 'inappropriate' sexting chats with female photographer
- Topless Missouri woman Jeanne Ouelette chases alleged Peeping Tom Jeremy Bradley
- New York residents kept awake by eerie howling from new One World Trade Centre
- Man charged after cops shoot bystanders
- Falmouth Family loses 2 sons weeks apart
- Foster child found chained to porch in North Carolina with dead chicken around his neck
- The more men want sex the more they lower their standards while frisky females RAISE theirs, new study finds
- Waitress receives rude note - internet response is epic
- Caran Johnson accidentally live tweets husband's fatal car crash
- Veteran skydiver Sean Carey plummets to death during competition
- IN PICTURES: The Drug Smuggling 'SUPER TUNNEL'
- ANOTHER black Barneys shopper Kayla Phillips, 21, claims she was racially profiled
- Rabbi Noah Muroff finds $100K of forgotten cash in desk bought on Craigslist
- Drunk hotel guest climbs into 12,000 litre aquarium for a swim
- Charges dropped for UVA student Elizabeth Daly in water-buying incident
- Thomas Liming, 21, charged in brutal murder of 'best friend' Kyle Underhill
- Jennifer Lee Wilson: Friends of Fulbright scholar 'stabbed to death by ex boyfriend' speak out
- Harriet Deison: Pastor's wife, 65, buys pistol from gun shop and shoots herself dead in the parking lot
- Black North Carolina pastor to church volunteers: "Only white people" at front door of church
- Jack Schaap: Megachurch pastor fired after picture of him kissing 16-year-old girl is found on his phone
- Meet the real-life Popeye and his 31 inch biceps
- Shocking image of toddler sipping a Bud Light at Cleveland Browns tailgate goes viral
- Pervert Pastor James Harris Found Guilty of Sex Acts swallowed mints, not pills, test shows
- Toni Annette Medrano: Woman who killed baby, dubbed 'Vodka Mom' by Nancy Grace, dies after setting self on fire
- Fort Bragg soldier Ruben Fox and wife arrested after having sex with dogs and posting videos of the acts online
- Jeremiah Fogle, 57, killed wife Theresa Brown and shot 2 pastors
- $10,000 found: Boy, 10, finds $10,000 in Kansas City hotel room
Rate this article
|PHOTOS: Plastic Surgery Celebrity||Awkward family photos|
|UPDATED: Faces of Meth||PHOTOS: Celebrities all a-Twitter|